I asked ChatGPT to analyze all the reviews and YouTube videos. And then I asked two questions that are on everyone’s mind here:
1) Why should someone sell his A1 and upgrade to the A1II?
Upgrading from the Sony A1 to the A1 II depends on your needs as a photographer or videographer. Here are the key reasons why an upgrade might be worth considering:
1. Significantly Enhanced Autofocus
AI Processor: The A1 II introduces a dedicated AI processor for advanced subject tracking, including “Human Pose Estimation” for better detection of faces, eyes, and bodies in dynamic scenarios.
Faster AF Calculations: Doubling the autofocus calculations to 120 times per second ensures better accuracy in fast-moving scenes.
2. Better Image Stabilization
The A1 II offers 8.5 stops of in-body image stabilization (up from 5.5 stops in the A1), a substantial improvement for handheld shooting, especially in low light.
3. Pre-Capture and Workflow Efficiency
Pre-Capture Feature: The ability to record up to 1 second of RAW images before fully pressing the shutter is a game-changer for capturing critical moments.
Enhanced workflow tools and refinements, such as speed boosts for burst shooting, help professionals operate more efficiently.
4. Improved Video Features
The A1 II retains the 8K/30p capability of the A1 but adds advanced thermal management, allowing for longer recording durations.
Video modes like Auto Framing and Framing Stabilizer enable dynamic subject tracking and more stable handheld footage.
5. Future-Proofing
With updated technology like the AI processor and enhanced stabilization, the A1 II is better suited to handle evolving demands, making it a more future-proof investment.
6. Edge in Competitive Scenarios
Professionals competing with cameras like the Nikon Z9 or Canon EOS R1 may find the A1 II’s advanced autofocus and video features necessary to remain competitive.
Why Stick with the A1?
If you don’t rely heavily on cutting-edge autofocus, ultra-stabilization, or advanced video features, the original A1 still offers top-tier resolution, speed, and versatility. The decision hinges on whether these incremental but meaningful upgrades justify the cost for your use case.
2) Why are people disappointed with the A1II ?
Some users and reviewers have expressed disappointment with the Sony A1 II, primarily because they perceive it as a more incremental update rather than a revolutionary leap over the original A1. Here are the main reasons for their criticisms:
1. Minimal Sensor and Image Quality Upgrades
The A1 II uses the same 50.1MP sensor as the original A1, with no significant increase in resolution or dynamic range. Many were expecting a next-generation sensor with higher resolution or improved low-light performance.
2. Limited 8K Video Improvements
While the A1 II can record 8K for longer durations due to better heat management, there is no leap in frame rates (still capped at 30fps) or advanced codec options that would set it apart from competitors like the Nikon Z9 or Canon EOS R5 Mark II.
3. High Price with Incremental Upgrades
The price of the A1 II remains at a premium level (~$6,500), but some argue that the updates—such as the AI processor, stabilization improvements, and autofocus tweaks—don’t justify the cost for those already using the original A1.
4. Lack of Game-Changing Features
Critics were hoping for groundbreaking innovations, such as global shutter technology, higher burst rates, or new video capabilities like internal raw recording. The absence of such features leaves some feeling underwhelmed.
5. Focus on Niche Improvements
Many of the upgrades, such as pre-capture and pose estimation, are valuable but appeal primarily to specific types of photographers (e.g., sports or wildlife). For general users, the original A1 already meets most needs.
Summary of Discontent
The A1 II is seen as a refinement of an already excellent camera, but for many professionals, the incremental nature of the improvements does not justify the upgrade—especially considering the cost. It remains a fantastic tool, but the lack of revolutionary changes has left some users disappointed.
And here is a way more funny explanation on why you have to update to the Sony A1II:
The above official teaser shows the 12mm RF lens on the left and the new Samyang AF35mm F1.4 P FE lens on the right
Samyang will soon announce the first lens with the “P” mark. It will be the 35mm F1.4 P autofocus Full Frame E-mount. It is not yet clear what the “P” stands for but this lens will have a special new lightweight construction.
Compared to the current existing Samyang 35mm AF lens the new lens will weight 470g instead of 659g. The lens barrel length is 12cm compared to 13.5cm for the previous generation. The minimum focusing distance is 30cm compared to 29cm for the previous generation. Additionally, the third generation also features a new lens hood and a new lens cap design.
