Skip to content

A Sony Menu Redesign suggestion by Per Kylberg.

Share

SAR reader Per Kylberg sent me this:

Many complain about Sony menu system and user interface. In my professional work with virtual systems, the thing that differentiates between a success implementation is the usability. Easy to learn and use UI equals not only happy users, management see lead time go down and quality up and thus are happy too.
Below is my idea about a more logical, photographer perspective, menu system. It would be interesting to see how a discussion and proposals from SAR community can improve this starting point menu organisation!

Complain and propose!

Background
As with most camera manufacturers, Sony rightfully are critizised for the camera user interface and in particular for the menues. At the presentation of the A7Rmk2 a Sony official was asked about the UI and menues. The reply was (as I remeber): ”Menues are up to the engineers to decide”.
Engineers are very good at product development, yes. But they are not experts in using the products! Being in technical documentation and managing virtual systems (in automotive) for 40+ years, I have plenty knowledge from both sides of the matter. Engineers are great! They develop excellent cameras with great functionality! But the user interface should be developed by experts in UI and usage.
The reason for this is that engineers, naturally, think ”inside – out”. UI needs be developed ”outside – in! By UI experts
”Outside” are we: the photographers.

As – is analyse
The A7 cameras have about 17 outside physical controls. Nikon D8xx have 32 of them if I remember right.
In the menu structure the A7 has:
– 6 main menues
– 28 no-name sub menues
– 153 execution commands
Where is the logic in this hierarchical build? What is for instance the difference between ”Camera settings” and ”Custom settings”? And why no-name menues? There are 22 execution commands concerning focusing, spread out in 10 different no-name submenues under two different main menues. Why?

”Maybe To-be” alternative A – hierarchial structure
To reach execution commands, there should be no time/energy consuming search. The structure must have an easy to understand and remember structure. There must be a clear logic based on how photographers think. This should a core issue for Sony.
Below is my discussion proposal consisting:
12 Main menues
14 Named sub menues
153 execution commands

Photo/video setup
image quality mode and setting Shutter Flash Display
-image size Drive mode E-front curt Shutter Flash mode Grid line
-aspect ratio Auto Mode Silent shooting Flash comp Live view display
RAW/JPG Format) Scene select Auto slow shutter Red eye redux Auto review
Long exposure NR Reset EV comp Finder/Monitor
High ISO NR Bracket settings
Color space Zoom setting
Steady shot
Steady shot settings
Ten last used
My menu
JPG unique
Panorama size S Auto img extract
Panorama direction Soft skin detect
Creative style Auto object framing
Picture effect
Picture style
Zoom
Focusing
General AF MF
Focus mode Center lock-on AF MF assist
Focus area Smile face detect Peaking color
Focus settings Eye start aF Peaking level
AF illum Priority set in AF-S Focus magnify time
AF drive speed Priority set in AF-C Focus magnifier
AF track sens AF system
Disp cont Af area Per AF
Phase detect area Face registration
ISO and metering
Exposure comp Zebra
Exposure step Exp,comp,set
ISO
ISO auto
Metering mode
White bal
DRO/ Auto HDR
Video unique
File format Marker display 4K output sel
record setting Marker settings
dual video record Video light mode
Movie HDMI settings
Sound unique
Audio record
Audio record level
Audio out timing
Wind noise redux
Audio level display
Customizing
Memory Function menu set Movie button
Memory recall Custom key set Dial/wheel lock
Disp button My menu set
AEL with shutter Dial setup
AF with shutter Dial EV comp
Finder/monitor Zoom ring rotate
Wireless and apps
Send smartphone WPS push App list
Send Computer Edit device name Introduction
View on TV DMAC address
NFC SSID/PW reset
Airplane mode Reset network set
Camera setup
Control Display Help Connect Manage
Volume settings Monitor brightness Demo mode Remote ctrl Copyright info
APS-C/Super 35mm Viewfinder brightness Exposure set guide USB conn Format (card)
Release w/o lens Finder color temp Mode dilal Guide USB power supply Select rec folder
Release w/o card Display quality NTSC/PAL select New folder
AF micro adj Display media info File name
Lens comp PWR save start time Recover image DB
Audio signals Version
Language Setting reset
Date/time setup Cleaning mode
Area setting TC/UB settings
Playback
Delete
View mode
Image index
Display rotation
Slide show
Rotate
Enlarge image
Protect
Specify printing
Delete confirm

And what do you think?

Share
Back To Top